TL;DR
Get business pricing on garage and car supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
A 2013 Audi Q5 belonging to Alicia Good was reportedly wrecked after an employee at AE German Car Service took it from the Hollywood shop. Good told Fox 11 Los Angeles that police said the handover of the keys could make a theft allegation difficult to pursue, but the circumstances and purpose of the drive remain unclear. The shop said the matter was being handled by its insurer.
A 2013 Audi Q5 belonging to Alicia Good was reportedly wrecked after an employee at AE German Car Service in Hollywood took the SUV from the shop and crashed it into a Jersey barrier, according to Fox 11 Los Angeles. Good had brought the vehicle in for a fluids check; the shop said it was handling the matter through its insurer, while the reason for the drive and the circumstances of the crash remain unclear.
Fox 11 reported that Good left the Q5 at the garage for a basic fluids check. The crash allegedly happened on the night of Sept. 4, about nine miles from the shop. The garage contacted her roughly 18 hours after the collision and said the SUV had struck a barrier while an employee had supposedly taken it home. It was later towed back to the business.
Video included in the report showed extensive damage: the front bumper was missing, the hood was bent upward, and the windshield was shattered. The report did not establish why the vehicle left the shop, whether the employee had permission to take it home, or what caused the collision. AE German Car Service declined to discuss the details with Fox 11, saying only that the matter was being handled by its insurance company.
Good told Fox 11 that the Los Angeles Police Department said the situation might not amount to auto theft because she had entrusted the shop with the keys. That is her account of what police told her, not a published police finding or a determination about civil liability. The available report does not say that prosecutors have filed charges or that an insurer has reached a decision.
Who May Be Responsible for the Damage
The case illustrates why the purpose and scope of a vehicle handover can matter after a shop employee crashes a customer’s car. A garage may need to drive a vehicle to diagnose or verify a repair, but a drive for personal use would raise different questions from a service-related test drive. Whether the drive was authorized, and what the employee was doing at the time, have not been established here.
Those facts may affect how an insurer evaluates the loss and whether the owner has grounds for further legal action. The report does not identify the applicable policy, say who will pay for the Q5, or resolve any question of criminal conduct. Good’s case remains an account of a reported incident, not a finding of fault.
Audi Q5 2013 dash camera front and rear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Is Known About the Shop Visit
Good reportedly brought the SUV to AE German Car Service for a fluids check, rather than describing a repair that clearly required an extended road test. The shop later told her, according to Fox 11, that the vehicle had hit a barrier while an employee had taken it home. The difference between a necessary service drive and personal use is central to the questions raised by the report, but the available account does not confirm which occurred.
The Drive also cited an earlier Tennessee case involving a customer’s Mercedes-Benz C300. In that case, a judge ruled for the owner after a mechanic took the car on what the defense described as an “extended test drive”; the owner had tracked it to a bar parking lot, and the mechanic was still tried for criminal theft. That separate dispute provides an example of how evidence about a vehicle’s use can matter, but it does not determine the outcome in Good’s case.
““It’s debatable whether or not it’s actually grand theft (auto) because I had entrusted them with my car.””
— Alicia Good, as quoted by Fox 11 Los Angeles
Audi Q5 2013 windshield replacement
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Details of the Drive Remain Unknown
The available reporting does not establish why the employee took the Audi home, whether Good or the shop authorized that trip, or whether the vehicle was being used for a service-related purpose when it crashed. It also does not specify the employee’s account, the cause of the impact, or whether any traffic violations were involved.
There is no reported final decision from the insurer, stated estimate for the damage, or confirmed outcome of any police investigation. The source material does not report a criminal charge, a civil filing by Good, or an official conclusion about responsibility. Those points should not be treated as settled based only on the owner’s account and the shop’s brief response.
Audi Q5 2013 front bumper cover replacement
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Insurance and Investigation Could Clarify
The immediate reported process is the shop’s insurance handling the matter. A decision may depend on evidence about the collision, the employee’s use of the SUV, and the relevant insurance coverage. No payment decision or claim outcome was reported in the available account.
Further information from Good, the shop, police, or the insurer could clarify whether the drive was authorized and what options are available to her. Until those details emerge, the question of who is financially or legally responsible remains unresolved.
car accident emergency documentation kit
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
What happened to Alicia Good’s Audi?
Fox 11 Los Angeles reported that Good’s 2013 Audi Q5 was wrecked after an employee at AE German Car Service allegedly took it from the Hollywood shop and hit a Jersey barrier. The SUV had been brought in for a fluids check.
Did the mechanic have permission to take the Audi home?
The available report does not establish whether the trip was authorized. The shop reportedly told Good that the employee had taken the vehicle home, but the purpose and permission for the drive remain unclear.
Did police decide that no crime occurred?
No formal police finding is reported. Good said police told her theft could be debatable because she had handed over the keys. That account does not establish whether an investigation is ongoing or whether charges will be considered.
Who will pay for the damage?
That has not been reported. AE German Car Service told Fox 11 that its insurance company was handling the matter, but no coverage decision, settlement, or payment was disclosed.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
